Nona Tepper: Welcome to Fashionable Healthcare’s Past the Byline, the place we provide a behind the scenes look into our reporting. I am Nona Tepper. I write about insurance coverage. Senior Operation’s Reporter, Alex, has joined me as we speak to speak about rural healthcare in Alabama. Thanks for becoming a member of me, Alex.
Alex Kacik: Hey Nona, thanks for having me.
Nona Tepper: So you latterly reported that about 21 rural hospitals have closed over the past two years. And, , as such, we have seen a hollowing out of the agricultural well being security internet as hospitals reduce providers to attempt to maintain these doorways open. How are rural hospitals faring in Alabama?
Alex Kacik: So a type of hospitals that closed over the past two years was Pickens County Medical Heart in west Alabama. It closed proper earlier than the pandemic in March. And there is numerous elements at play right here, however certainly one of them is Alabama selected to not increase Medicaid, which is partially why 84% of their rural hospitals are dropping cash. A lot of their hospitals reduce much less worthwhile providers, such as you talked about. Obstetrics is commonly one of many first ones to go, and labor and supply. So we have seen that all through numerous rural communities throughout the nation. And this has led to fairly huge care gaps, that means that folk are having to journey farther from their communities to get care, and that compounds well being outcomes. However I talked to hospitals in Demopolis, in Centreville, which might be including sure service traces to maintain of us of their group, and that helps these greater tutorial medical facilities as a result of they may take care of the sickest of the sick and retain their beds for essentially the most advanced instances in locations like Birmingham and Tuscaloosa.
Nona Tepper: Effectively, that is fascinating. So as an alternative of truly closing down providers as a option to reduce prices, they’re really including providers and investing of their supplier system. Is that proper?
Alex Kacik: Yeah. So the preliminary response by numerous monetary executives which might be, are operating hospitals is to attempt to reduce away at numerous providers which might be much less worthwhile. And, , you do have that case that occurs perhaps early on, however over time you might even see providers proceed to wind down if financials do not enhance. However there’s a number of hospitals in Alabama which have adopted a concept the place for those who add providers that are not properly represented locally, typically round main care, eye care, wound care, relying in your inhabitants, you’ll be able to maintain of us in your area people after which you would add these wraparound providers. And so, that usually builds on one another. As you keep extra sufferers, you’ll be able to maintain them in your hospital by including add-on providers as one of many executives described it to me. So, yeah. Effectively, a type of was Whitfield Regional.
Nona Tepper: That is an enchanting strategy and really completely different from what it feels like the remainder of the trade is doing. I do know you talked about that one of many hospitals was Whitfield Regional Medical Heart in Demopolis. They had been on the verge of closing a number of years in the past, however then Marengo County voters and UAB Medication helped proper the ship. What occurred at Whitfield?
Alex Kacik: So, Whitfield had misplaced about $20 million from 2008 to 2018, so over a ten 12 months interval. So it did initially reduce obstetrics providers in 2013 to attempt to stabilize. However then after that, a specialist left, after which there was this associated financial ripple impact all through the county. Marengo County voters handed a property tax enhance a pair years in the past. And UAB Medication shaped a medical affiliation with Whitfield to maintain sufferers in its hospital by way of telehealth providers. Specialists are few and much to return by in rural areas, so UAB has its affiliations with the native colleges and has the pipeline of specialists coming by their programs. So, they provide consulting providers with like 9 rural hospitals in Alabama. And certainly one of which is Whitfield. So you may have a specialist information care by way of telehealth. So, , their video feed seems as, , they’re treating the affected person, diagnosing them. And they also assist maintain advanced instances in terms of of us with extreme kidney issues, perhaps lung illness, stroke sufferers, and different important care, they maintain them of their group. So their drives are shorter and in addition their liberating up area at UAB for tertiary care.
So now Whitfield is bringing again obstetric providers subsequent 12 months, after it has been capable of retain many extra sufferers. It isn’t solely retaining extra sufferers, it is case counts went up. Simply common each day census has gone up considerably. Its affected person combine is far more advanced. So it is allowed them to open up a brand new breast most cancers clinic, imaging providers, cardiovascular care, eye surgical procedure, and gastrointestinal providers, amongst others. And so, I used to be capable of discuss with some of us to determine what the affect of the group was.
Nona Tepper: That is fascinating. So primarily by letting its sufferers go to with UAB Medication clinicians by telehealth, and it feels like UAB Medication perhaps even will get to maintain the money from these visits. Whitfield has really been capable of retain and develop its membership. Is that appropriate?
Alex Kacik: Yeah, that is proper. So Whitfield has 99 licensed beds and it was working at a median each day census of between 12 and 20 individuals earlier than the pandemic. That has jumped to about 51 now. So I am not precisely positive on the monetary association, however, , I feel Whitfield and the opposite hospitals, they’ve a month-to-month price with the UAB Medication for these consulting providers. And on the DRG billing, I am not precisely positive how that works out.
However I feel in the end, as they’re capable of maintain extra of us within the system, they may add all these wraparounds providers, which has helped so much at Whitfield Regional. Its sufferers are extra acute, which suggests it will get paid extra. Now it is including issues like wound care and infusions for its disproportionately excessive quantity of sufferers with continual illness. So you could have numerous of us which might be affected by diabetes, as an illustration. So this wound care clinic, their wound care providers that they’ve arrange, permits them to type of keep in a single place. So as an alternative of touring an hour or two hours to the massive tutorial medical middle, they may keep within the space.
Nona Tepper: Wow. So shorter journey occasions and perhaps a better belief of their native supplier, which is all the time good for each group. I do know you talked about Jo Fitz-Gerald earlier. Are you able to inform me somewhat bit about her?
Alex Kacik: So Jo Fitz-Gerald is a candy 83-year-old grandmother of 12 I talked with. She was recognized with breast most cancers lately, and normally she must drive to Tuscaloosa, which was greater than an hour from her hometown in Demopolis. However since Whitfield simply opened its breast most cancers clinic, she may keep near house. So she goes for each day remedies, and it is solely a seven minute drive. Her most cancers’s receding after a number of weeks of each day radiation. And he or she was telling me that the hospital, after years of being financially unstable, is doing a lot better and has, and can, save lives as of us can get care nearer to house.
Nona Tepper: Undoubtedly. Effectively, that is a terrific story. And congratulations to Miss Fitz-Gerald.
So I do know you and our knowledge journalist, Tim Broderick, checked out rural hospitals Medicare value stories, and there was one thing distinctive about Alabama hospitals. What did the info present?
Alex Kacik: So, a part of the explanation we targeted on Alabama was that it has the bottom share of important entry hospitals per capita within the nation. It has lower than 0.1 per 100,000 inhabitants. Averages are a lot greater in like neighboring Mississippi, the place it has, , nearer to 3 or 4. So the important entry program was shaped in 1997 for hospitals which have fewer than 25 beds and are 35 miles away from one other hospital. They get a slight enhance within the Medicare reimbursement. However the of us I talked with mentioned the political will wasn’t there in Alabama to pursue the designation. The primary business insurer on the time, I feel Blue Cross, paid them comparatively properly. However that, over time, dwindled, as , as insurers are attempting to cut back, , the price of care and their overhead.
And that 35 mile designation precluded numerous hospitals from transitioning. Plus most had been over 25 beds and that may require them to pare down of providers, which is a tricky promote typically. There is a proposed regulation that may cast off that 35 mile provision. However the monetary specialists I talked with mentioned that the gaining the important entry designation would not assist that a lot within the case of those Alabama hospitals, given their a affected person and payer combine.
So additionally beginning in 2023, hospitals may eliminate roughly all of their inpatient care and qualify for a brand new program referred to as the Rural Emergency Hospital Program. It provides you a 5% enhance to Medicare reimbursement plus month-to-month facility price funds. However a lot of the of us I talked to in Alabama, weren’t occupied with winding down their inpatient beds and swing beds and providers. They mentioned, specifically, with out these rural hospitals, the pandemic would’ve been so much worse as a result of they wanted all the additional search capability that was out there.
Nona Tepper: Yeah. It feels like this program really would type of do the alternative of what Miss Fitz-Gerald like benefited from. It might really proceed to chop providers, however simply as one other option to achieve more money, is that appropriate?
Alex Kacik: Yeah. So, in eliminating inpatient providers is all the time a tricky promote. It appears as just like the spine of a group, , from an financial standpoint and simply from a security standpoint. So, , we have executed some reporting in 2017 the place we checked out, , common each day census counts, and throughout the nation, rural hospital’s inpatient beds had been solely a 38% full on common, which made it arduous to maintain. You realize, there’s been numerous criticism on how type of rural hospitals function and advocating for them to roughly function as a free standing emergency division, solely like observations providers and outpatient providers. However the of us I talked with in Alabama, , they mentioned that with out these rural hospitals being there, the, , tertiary medical facilities would’ve been much more overrun.
So within the case of Whitfield, , with the assistance of UAB Medication specialists and telestroke and Tele-ICU and telenephrology, , they’re capable of maintain important care sufferers of their amenities, ensuring that UAB’s hospital beds had been reserved for the sickest of COVID sufferers. As of now, almost two-thirds of rural hospitals don’t have intensive care beds, in line with knowledge from Constitution Heart for Rural Well being. So which means that many had been woefully under-prepared for sufferers who wanted ventilators and different important care. So it has shifted the conversations on what position rural hospital ought to play.
Nona Tepper: So is Whitfield like a case examine for the remainder of the trade? Like ought to the remainder of each rural hospital, , simply be clinically affiliating with bigger programs to realize telehealth providers, or ought to they be seeking to have interaction specialists by telehealth?
Alex Kacik: I feel these medical affiliations have gotten extra prevalent. So numerous occasions they’re by like joint ventures or different casual partnerships. You do not essentially have to personal a few of these hospitals to have a few of these medical affiliations. They usually’re rising in frequency, the place you are seeing a, , mutually helpful association between the massive well being system and the smaller hospital that, , permits not solely the smaller hospitals to make the most of their specialty experience, however they will additionally faucet into a few of their, , administrative infrastructure in terms of IT and billing and coding. And a few of that may be taken on by the larger system as a result of they’ve the size, and it is simply not that a lot of a burden as it could be on a smaller facility.
Nona Tepper: What are another ways in which rural well being care can, these programs can maintain themselves? What does the outlook seem like?
Alex Kacik: So, , teachers and consultants I discuss with are hopeful the agricultural emergency hospital program will assist stabilize rural hospitals, however that may entail slicing in-patient providers, which is rarely a straightforward promote. There may be an pressing want for rural hospitals to seek out all different income streams. And the oldsters I talked with mentioned there are alternatives within the 340B drug low cost program, and behavioral well being, significantly for on the 340B entrance for people that qualify for the disproportionate share hospital funding. So, , rural hospitals, like all others are having to pay their workers extra just like different healthcare suppliers, and people prices aren’t going away. So they are going to want to seek out methods to maintain sufferers of their group and add some ancillary providers to herald extra income.
Nona Tepper: Effectively, thanks to your time and thanks all for listening. It feels like Whitfield was, a minimum of partly, ready to try this.
If you would like to subscribe and help our work, there is a hyperlink within the present notes. It’s also possible to subscribe to the Past the Byline on Spotify or wherever you take heed to your podcasts. You’ll be able to keep related with our work by following Alex and I at Fashionable Healthcare on Twitter and LinkedIn. We respect your help.
