A federal chapter choose in North Carolina has quickly halt roughly 38,000 lawsuits towards Johnson & Johnson that declare the corporate’s child powder was contaminated with cancer-causing asbestos.
AFP Contributor/AFP through Getty Photos
cover caption
toggle caption
AFP Contributor/AFP through Getty Photos
A federal chapter choose in North Carolina has quickly halt roughly 38,000 lawsuits towards Johnson & Johnson that declare the corporate’s child powder was contaminated with cancer-causing asbestos.
AFP Contributor/AFP through Getty Photos
A federal chapter choose in North Carolina agreed Wednesday to quickly halt roughly 38,000 lawsuits towards Johnson & Johnson that declare the corporate’s child powder was contaminated with cancer-causing asbestos.
However Choose Craig Whitley solely delayed the instances for 60 days. He additionally dominated that the case ought to be heard in New Jersey, the place J&J is headquartered, and never in North Carolina.
“It is a main setback for J&J,” stated Adam Levitin, a chapter professional at Georgetown College, writing on Twitter. “J&J will get a 60 day keep of litigation…however that is all.”
🚨 J&J LTL talc chapter venue to be transferred to New Jersey. Texas Two-Step turns into a Trenton Tango.
J&J will get a 60 day stat of litigation towards mother or father corp, however that’s all.
It is a main setback for J&J.
— Adam Levitin (@AdamLevitin) November 10, 2021
Johnson & Johnson faces an avalanche of lawsuits linked to claims that traces of asbestos in its child powder precipitated ovarian most cancers and mesothelioma. The corporate introduced in November final yr that its talc powder could be removed from shelves within the U.S. and Canada.
J&J and LTL needed the child powder lawsuits frozen throughout a case evaluation that might take years
Final month, J&J used a controversial legal maneuver generally known as the “Texas Two-Step” as a part of an try and restrict its authorized legal responsibility.
First, the corporate created a brand new subsidiary known as LTL in Texas and shoved all its baby-powder-related legal responsibility into the brand new firm.
Then the brand new agency LTL rapidly filed for chapter in North Carolina, a federal chapter venue seen as favorable for this type of maneuver due to earlier rulings.
J&J and LTL additionally requested that the tsunami of child powder lawsuits be frozen whereas the chapter case is reviewed, a course of that might take years.
From the outset, nevertheless, the federal choose assigned to the case has voiced skepticism about J&J’s technique. On Wednesday, Choose Whitley despatched the case again to New Jersey and granted solely a restricted, two-month keep of lawsuits.
J&J did not reply to NPR’s request for remark, however the firm’s new subsidiary LTL despatched a press release expressing disappointment.
“Though we imagine this case was correctly venued in North Carolina, we are going to proceed to work with all events to hunt an environment friendly and equitable decision,” the assertion learn.
LTL additionally maintained as soon as once more that, “Johnson’s Child Powder is secure, doesn’t include asbestos and doesn’t trigger most cancers.”
The 60-day delay permits a brand new choose taking on to “rise up to hurry on the problems”
Andy Birchfield, an lawyer at Beasley Allen who represents lots of the plaintiffs suing J&J, praised Wednesday’s rulings.
“This matter logically belongs in New Jersey the place J&J is headquartered and the place greater than 30,000 victims search justice,” Birchfield stated in a press release.
Birchfield described the 60-day delay of lawsuits as a “trip,” which is able to enable a brand new choose taking on the case to “rise up to hurry on the problems.”
This case comes as a rising variety of bipartisan lawmakers have condemned use of chapter courts by non-bankrupt corporations and billionaires to dam lawsuits.
“One other large company is abusing our chapter system to defend its belongings and evade legal responsibility for the hurt it has precipitated folks throughout the nation,” Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., tweeted final month.
