- This post contains affiliate links. Read more here.
- Not a substitute for professional veterinary help.
Peanut meal and dog treats are incredibly useful and versatile — add them to licking mats or other puzzle food dispensers, bake with or freeze them, or place them on top of dry crumbs as treats feed to reluctant eaters or dogs prone to dehydration (most contain water, broth, or milk as a main ingredient). Or use them to help with certain medications!
Peanut butter is also very high in calories, which means there is an art to incorporating them in your pet’s diet. “When people use fillers, it’s surprising that their dogs are overweight and they don’t even realize it.” Dr. Rebecca GreensteinVeterinary Medical Advisor to Rover and Chief Veterinarian at Kleinburg Veterinary Hospital.
That’s a reason better than dog-specific peanut butter to cheaper human options you find in your grocery store: dog products often cut down on fat, sugar, and salt, things a dog’s palate won’t ignore, to favor Nutritious ingredients, safe for dogs. But even these dog-healthy peanut butters pack a ton of calories, which is why it’s better to stock your puppy’s food with lower-impact fillers. .
With the help of some Rover test pups, we’ve compiled and ranked the best high-value dog peanut butters, spreadable foods, and low-calorie fillers to keep your dog healthy. Your dog is always happy and healthy.
The Best Peanut Butters Dogs
If a concise all-natural ingredient list is what you’re after, look no further than these peanut butters for dogs. They’re also quite versatile: bake with them, freeze them in Kongs, or hide the medicine in a teaspoon. The jars are also some of the best value, even if they can be a bit messier than packets or tubes.
The best all-purpose peanut butter for dogs: Bark Bistro Buddy Budder (Verified review)
Lots of baby mice (including us) love Buddy Budder, variety of flavors. This dish has only two ingredients: peanuts and honey. Like the other peanut butters on our list, Buddy Budder uses only whole-food ingredients that are both safe for dogs and nutritious for canines. Generally 80 calories per tablespoon and around $0.87 per ounce, it’s a good mid-sugar option both in calories and cost.
We found this to be the most contagious type of peanut residue in the world mat lick (especially when stored in the fridge) and is the most versatile of all peanut butters for dogs in general.
Shop on Chewy
Shopping on Amazon
With just peanuts, chia seeds, and coconut oil, here’s peanut butter for dogs that humans can love, too. The oil separates, so it should be kept in the fridge (or even upside down – a pro tip we’ve gathered from reviewers and found to work well). We found it a bit messy to hide pills or spread on licking rugs, but we love it for freezing or incorporating into recipes. homemade baked dog food.
With 124 calories per tablespoon, which is one of the most expensive butters on our list. Best for dogs that are insensitive or have fat problems, as ingredients like coconut oil or even the oils in peanuts can be great for some dogs’ digestive systems.
With no grains, corn, wheat, added sugar or artificial flavors, this dog peanut butter comes in an easy-to-squeeze sachet and gives your dog all the goodness of peanut butter with little to no mess. much more than jars and spoons. For a simple “dumpling” treat, put some of these in your freezer for a summer treat, no dishes needed! It’s true that you make less for your money, but sometimes we think it’s worth the extra cent to have a comfort food in the first place.
Shopping on Amazon Shop on Chewy
The best budget dog peanut butter: Dilly’s Poochie Butter (Verified review)
This peanut butter dog treat is made with five ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, parsley, turmeric, ginger, and flaxseed. It has no added sugar (and just two grams total) and no sodium, making it a human peanut butter. It also gives the best performance for your money at $0.78 per ounce.
Shopping on Amazon
Shop on Rover Store
All you find in this jar are American-grown peanuts and flaxseeds. However, what sets it apart from the competition is its relatively low-calorie formula. While a tablespoon of Buddy Budder and similar peanut butters for dogs typically contains an 80-calorie snack, Green Coast Pet’s Pawnut Butter is an impressive treat. 47 calories per tablespoon.
At $0.94 per ounce, Pawnut Butter is one of the more expensive dog peanut butters on our list. But sometimes a calorie-affordable option can be worth its weight in gold for peanut butter lovers.
The best treatments can spread to dogs
These treats may or may not have a peanut butter flavor, but they typically contain fewer calories per serving than the naturally rich treats above. Some are made with only natural ingredients and most have water or another liquid as the main ingredient.
Costing less than $4 per tube, a little of this contagious canine medicament will go a long way. It comes in several flavors, including peanut butter, bacon and cheese, smoked sausageand Liver. It hits some extra fun: It’s mess-free, and it’s easy to apply to anything you want your dog to obsess over, such as Kong or other auxiliary processing jigsaw toys (or on a Brick wall next to the bathtub). It is also a gentler alternative to peanut butter for dogs that are high in calories, but have a similar texture to nut butter.
Unlike some other spreads, this one is milk based and do contains some artificial preservatives and flavors, so if your dog has a food sensitivities related to those, look closely at the ingredients list.
Shop on Chewy Shop on Petco Shopping on Amazon
We can see why Churu spreads are dominating the internet! Made with all-natural ingredients and cooked with water and chicken, this is drier than many dog peanut butters, ideal as a small toast and for reluctant eaters. Our testers were bewildered about the taste.
That said, if it’s a licking rug or Kong filler you’re after, consistency makes it better for bowl style rug and toys than traditional options.
Made with chicken and beef, these puree packets are perfect as dry, pressed paper napkins that have a slightly mushy consistency but are a bit firm when they come out of the package. At under $20 for 32 ampoules, it’s by far one of the best budget options among pack-style spreadables. (Though we’re not entirely sure what makes this especially for small and small dogs – our medium dog loves it just as much!)
Dog treats and butter can spread in your pantry
If you’re looking to add a little variety to your dog’s food, chances are you have several items in your pantry that will do the trick. Pumpkin, apple sauce, bananas, and even baby food (as long as you avoid ingredients are not dog friendly) are all dog-safe, spreadable options for a licking pad or food tray.
Best for digestion: Organic Pumpkin Nummy Tum-Tum
Available in a 12-pack, this sugar-free canned pumpkin is marketed for pets in a BPA-free liner, but humans can also enjoy it. All you find in this can is USDA organic pumpkin.
Other family options:
How do we choose?
The products featured here were selected based on a combination of our own hands-on testing, comprehensive review of customer reviews across multiple retail platforms, and interviews with veterinary professionals. , including Rover’s Dog People Panel. We’ve weighed calories per tablespoon, price per ounce, ingredient list, texture, and consistency to bring you the best peanut butter for dogs and spreadable treats. We are also guided by our own experience of living and playing with our own much-loved and steadfast pets, who are never stingy with their feedback.
Read more
